Words or Action?


I am mailing the following letter to B.C.'s premier, two cabinet ministers, and Adam Olson as I believe this issue cuts to the core of our relationship with Indigenous peoples and sets the direction of the future of British Columbia. Are we really prepared to leave behind our colonial past, or do so in words only?

Feel free to also mail your version (or a copy of) this letter. The more people that actually snail mail the government the more likely their words will be put into action. I am grateful that a retired journalist and a member of the Anglican church in Nelson took the time to research and write this letter.


Hon. John Horgan,
Premier of BC
Legislative Assembly
West Annex Parliament Buildings 
Victoria, BC V8V 1X4
john.horgan.mla@leg.bc.ca


RE: BC Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act


Dear Premier Horgan:

I was pleased to note from the government website

https://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/governments/indigenous-people/new-relationship/frequently-asked-questions-the-united-nations-declaration-on-the-rights-of-indigenous-peoples that implementing the UN Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples  in B.C. is about ending discrimination, upholding basic human rights and ensuring more economic justice and fairness.

Given your government’s stated willingness to implement this Declaration, I would like to draw your attention to two issues: that of the construction of the Site C Dam and the expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline.
1) In 2014, you stated in a filmed interview that First Nations in the Peace region of the Site C Dam had entrenched constitutional rights that were “going to be violated by this dam.” However, on December 11, 2017, your government announced its decision to complete the dam. Following six months of confidential talks with the B.C. government and BC Hydro aimed at avoiding litigation, the West Moberly First Nations has announced it will proceed with a Site C dam court challenge, saying it infringes on their treaty rights. Apparently, the talks went nowhere. 
2) Indigenous groups involved in the court challenge against Trans Mountain are the Tsleil-Waututh and Squamish Nations in Metro Vancouver, the Coldwater Indian Band in Merritt and a coalition of First Nations in the Fraser Valley. Although the court has ruled that upcoming arguments can only focus on whether the latest round of Indigenous consultation was adequate., the Tsleil-Waututh and three environmental groups sought leave to appeal that ruling in the Supreme Court of Canada, claiming the Federal Court was wrong to refuse to hear arguments about the risk of an oil spill or threats to endangered southern killer whales.


Lastly, when the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples was adopted in 2007, it introduced the right to Free, Prior and Informed Consent for Indigenous Peoples. FPIC is one of the fundamental aspects of the UN Declaration and is included in six Articles.  While all six Articles are significant, Article 32.1 is of particular interest to the extractive resource sector in Canada:

Article 32.1
States shall consult and cooperate in good faith with the indigenous peoples concerned through their own representative institutions in order to obtain their free and informed consent prior to the approval of any project affecting their lands or territories and other resources, particularly in connection with the development, utilization or exploitation of mineral, water or other resources. 

If the government of BC is indeed implementing this Declaration, how is it that we are continuing to build the Site C Dam and the expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline?
Is this not duplicitous on the part of the government? Are you not aware that the United Nations and Amnesty International have called on Canada to stop building the Site C dam until proper consultations have taken place and that British Columbia has the authority to stop the dam?

It is not possible to pick and choose. Implementing the Declaration means that Indigenous peoples have the right to free, prior and informed consent regarding any utilization or exploitation of resources, including the building of the Site C Dam and the expansion of the Trans Mountain Pipeline across Indigenous land.


I am considering this issue to be so important for the future of our great province that I have decided to make it a public letter.

I would very much appreciate a reply to this letter. In fairness I will post your reply.



Sincerely,


Ian Gartshore
353 Seventh St.
Nanaimo, B.C.
V9R 1E3

Copies:  Hon. George Heyman, MLA
              Minister of Environment and Climate Change Strategy
              Room 112 Parliament Buildings 
              Victoria, BC V8V 1X4
  george.heyman.MLA@leg.bc.ca
Michelle Mungall, MLA Nelson-Creston
              Minister of Energy, Mines and Petroleum Resources
              Legislative Assembly: Room 301 Parliament Buildings 
              Victoria, BC V8V 1X4
              michelle.mungall.MLA@leg.bc.ca

Adam Olson, MLA
              Parliament Buildings
              Victoria, BC  V8V 1X4


Comments

Post a Comment

Thank you for commenting on this post. Your comment will be moderated before being posted in order to remove spammers.

Popular posts from this blog

Why the NDP has Failed its Supporters

Image
The New Democratic Party has made a vital contribution to both Canada and British Columbia. Once considered to be the "social conscience" of politics, pushing for more progressive policies that benefit workers and the general population. Our national health care system and other notable services came into existence largely through its initiative. As more of us became aware that we utterly rely on a healthy planetary home, the NDP began to include this in its messaging. Eventually the NDP became a coalition of sorts, bringing together its labour wing with its environmental wing. While its labour wing has always been more important for financial and other reasons, many earth-friendly people supported or voted for the NDP, claiming that voting Green was "splitting the vote." As it turns out this is about as true as believing the earth is flat. But it is a belief that has been propagated by the mainstream parties, especially the sometimes acrimonious members of the NDP.
Read more

A Third Approach to the COVID-19 Pandemic; Diversifying our Options

Image
The issue A tremendous amount of fear and anger are presently being felt and expressed in our society over the COVID-19 pandemic. Most of us are tired of the restrictions, especially the lack of easy physical proximity and/or contact, and all of us want this to be over. Those who will not (or cannot) be vaccinated are concerned about their health. Those who have been vaccinated but fear being infected by the un-vaccinated also fear for their health, and believe that if everyone did accept the vaccine the pandemic would finally end. Health authorities and the province are putting a lot of pressure on the un-vaccinated to get the jab. The un-compliant are experiencing a great deal of shaming and shunning. Some of these have become angry (shame often does that) and/or depressed ; some have become militant, organising marches on hospitals and other public sites. This only enrages the public. The battle lines deepen. Nobody is winning this battle. Let’s step back for a moment here.
Read more

Reducing homelessness, increasing livability

Image
Simplistic and populist politicians frequently fail to appreciate the long-term consequences of their platform and thrust. Dropping a stone into a still pond send ripples in every direction. Everything is connected and related to some extent; those who have eyes to see will recognise this truth in human activities. I understand the hardships being experienced by increasing numbers of people in the world due to the inflationary effects of higher fossil fuel costs. The ‘ripples’ from their excessive profits have impacted the price of food (largely grown on oil/gas dependent chemical fertilisers, pesticides and other inputs), oil-dependent transportation, and virtually everything else. Now interest rates are rapidly climbing, further impacting those who have limited incomes. In the same way, cities negatively impact the cost of living (and far more) by being car-centric. The physical space to accommodate the automobile takes up valuable real estate that would otherwise be available for
Read more